Since no one has been asking my opinion about the whole Dick Cheney speaking at BYU thing, I figured I would volunteer my opinions (as a Cougar alumni and all). I borrowed some of these opinions from NPR call in-ers who also had a lot to say, but mostly these are my own thoughts.
Surprisingly, I am not outraged that Dick Cheney is coming to BYU. If I were President Samuelson, I think I would have done the same thing, but I would be bummed if I was graduating and he was my commencement speaker.
Let's face it, how often does a university like BYU get to have a vice-president speak on campus? Not often. It is one of those honors that are hard to pass by.
"But Dick Cheney doesn't represent the school's values" - No he doesn't, but I am sure that at one point, like
Smeagol of old, he was a better man. I think the current administration is as close to fascism as any I am familiar with (which really isn't that many), but I still maintain that he will not be spending his 45 minutes at a BYU podium defending the ridiculous things he has pushed for in DC (which is a whole other discussion). I'm sure his talk will be tasteful, reserved, conservative, and that the words he says will be in line with BYU's values, even if his example isn't.
In defense of Cecil Samuelson, I am sure it was difficult to allow such a divisive and partisan public figure as VP Cheney to come. He was certainly aware that it would cause some waves on campus. But you know what I say, it is better to have some waves every once in a while. It makes the students think more (even if the thoughts are, "Boy it is lame that Cheney is speaking at my graduation").
It also makes graduation more memorable. I graduated at the last Commencement ceremonies BYU held. That makes it less than 7 months ago. I have no idea who spoke at commencement - don't even recall the gender. I wouldn’t forget if the VP were my commencement speaker.
It also gives a greater identity to BYU's leftward-leaning students and faculty - those who don't blindly accept anything a Republican politician says as a good idea. A little common dissent among them will lead to more opinions being shared on campus, and more opinions being shared at BYU will hopefully help to expose some very naive BYU students to the fact that you don't need to be a republican yes-man to be a reasonable and contributing member of society.
The vocal nature of the arguments will also be good in that it will give liberal BYU students and faculty more unity and publicity. It will help to further establish the weaker side of the political spectrum. In the long run, that could be very beneficial because it will prevent political discourse from being so one-sided.
So basically, while the situation isn't ideal, I think there are some overlooked silver linings to the otherwise cloudy day coming to BYU.